Bald Head Island Conservancy

Deer Management

Content Image

Project Overview

Bald Head Island provides excellent habitat for the white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus). Since there is no hunting allowed on Bald Head Island and there are few incidents of mortality due to vehicle collisions and a lack of top predators, the deer population thrives and can reach unsustainable numbers. Previously, the deer population has been managed using an annual cull to maintain the population below 200 individuals to ensure minimal impacts to the maritime forest. BHI Conservancy conducts annual population surveys, including summer spotlight surveys conducted along the roads and golf course for 25 nights over the course of the summer. In fall, we conduct a camera index using camera sites baited with corn to capture photos of tagged vs. untagged does and calculate a population estimate using mark-recapture equations. We use the male:female ratio from spotlight surveys and the tagged:untagged and doe: fawn ratios from camera index to calculate a population number each year. View historic white-tailed deer population numbers for BHI here.

Non-lethal deer population management was tested on BHI from 2014 – 2020 using a novel method called immunocontraception. For this project, female deer were vaccinated with a tested and EPA approved pharmaceutical drug called GonaCon™, which is produced by the USDA Wildlife Services. This program was the first and only permitted deer immunocontraception program in North Carolina and as such served as a test case for this type of non-lethal population control. This method was found to be effective at reducing deer pregnancy rates and limiting population growth, but was also expensive and logistically challenging. Immunocontraception can be used to decrease birth rates, but cannot reduce population size in the short-term. The Village and Conservancy may consider this method in the future once the deer population is within the target range.

IMMUNOCONTRACEPTION PROJECT (2014-2020)

The birth control vaccine, Gonacon™ was administered to female deer. To vaccinate the deer, BHIC scientists would first anesthetize them using a dart projector to remotely administer anesthesia drugs. Darting took place from baiting stations established around the island as well as from roadsides, at dusk and into the night. Once the deer was anesthetized, we would vaccinate her, assess her health, apply tracking devices, and inject a reversal drug to counteract the anesthesia. To assess deer health we would check her age, general physical condition, and draw blood to test for disease and pregnancy. This information would allow us to closely monitor the health of our deer herd. To monitor the health of the deer after anesthesia we would apply a lightweight radio collar to track the deer and numbered ear tags to identify individuals. Some of the tags have a matching number (one on each ear, e.g. 100-100) and some are chronological (e.g., 7-8), which has no specific meaning, but all deer are given two ear tags in case one comes out. Each deer would need two doses of Gonacon™ over two consecutive years to be considered fully vaccinated. The drug loses its effectiveness over time and our research shows that it is fully reversible.

The Conservancy would use radio telemetry to track deer wearing a radio collar for a few purposes: 1) we would track any individual that had been captured daily for two weeks to check for health and capture myopathy (death related to capture); 2) we would aim to track individuals needing their second dose for a full year so that we could more easily track it down in Year 2 for recapture.

Immunocontraception was effective: pregnancy samples collected from 2017 – 2020 showed that two doses reduced pregnancy from 100% to 13%. The immunocontraception program also stabilized deer population numbers during this time. 

The Immunocontraception program cost approximately $55,000 per year to administer in 2020, after multiple years of running the program. It would cost approximately $100,000 to start up the immunocontraception program again, and approximately $80,000 per year after that to administer.

SPOTLIGHT SURVEY PROTOCOL

Each summer since 2007, the BHI Conservancy and project partners have used the same routes and methods to conduct a spotlight survey to estimate white-tailed deer populations. On clear nights after sunset, our team drives a golf cart through the survey route, using high-powered spotlights with a red filter to search for deer. When a deer is spotted, the team stops to observe the deer through binoculars, noting the sex and age and any identifying characteristics. The average number of deer per night and area surveyed are scaled up to the total available deer habitat on the island to come up with a population size estimate and sex ratio. During spotlight surveys, we also survey for mesopredators (foxes and coyotes) and this is also used as a population index for these two species.

CAMERA INDEX PROTOCOL

Each fall, the Conservancy uses camera traps at sites throughout the island baited with corn to take photos of the deer population and calculate their population size. We take advantage of the fact that we have identifiable deer that have numbered ear tags (applied during immunocontraception captures) to use a mark-recapture methodology to calculate the population size. We set up trail cameras at 12 sites and set out corn to attract deer to the sites for at least 14 days. We sort the photos and calculate tagged:untagged ratios of does and count fawns. We use the male:female ratio from summer spotlight surveys to estimate the number of bucks from the number of does seen at cameras. The “official” number of deer reported by the Conservancy is the one generated from the fall camera index, available at the end of the year.